‘Above all, it’s the symbolism that matters’ – Polly Toynbee answered your questions on Andy Burnham’s first week

The UK's New Government and Foreign Policy

As the UK enters a new era with Ed Miliband and Andy Burnham at the helm, citizens are eager to know how their foreign policy will change. A key question concerns the country's stance on the Middle East and its potential for raising the UK's moral standing.

Polly Toynbee, a renowned expert on foreign policy, reflected on past experiences, citing the example of Robin Cook's 'ethical dimension' in the 1990s. During that time, the UK played a significant role in promoting human rights and democracy abroad, while also participating in international treaties like the ban on anti-personnel landmines.

However, Toynbee also acknowledged that previous leaders have not consistently adhered to these principles. She noted that Blair's government was accused of using the 'ethical policy' to justify the invasion of Iraq, while other instances, such as selling Hawk jets to Indonesia's oppressive regime, demonstrated the complexities of implementing an 'ethical' foreign policy.

Considering these nuances, Toynbee cautioned against expecting complete purity from the new government. Rather, she believes that a more outspoken and brave approach to human rights issues, such as the treatment of Palestinians and the ongoing conflict in Gaza, could be achieved.